Quote:
I'm sorry IB, but I did take a good look at it, and looked at each individual's response. I noticed your response to Reli, but said what i did anyway. I don't know why I did, but I did.
I'm not particularly good with spriting, or sprites in general, so, I can't really give any good, hardened, constructive criticism. All I can really say is that the 'eye' doesn't look so much like a human eye as more just a few pixels of black, or something. I zoomed in, and can see that you did put some white next to the purple eye, but maybe a second column of white would define it better? Also, the facial outline to the right of that eye gives the impression to me that there is more face, like it's head is turned. If the outline where more definitive, maybe it would help with that. ?The thumb seems to be jutting out at an odd angle on the non-pokeball hand.
I never thought you one for assuming things, then riding on people for what you assumed they did. That's kind of what it sounded like to me. Were you simply in a bad mood when you replied? -NyteFyre
Quote:
NyteFyre, I didn't assume anything. If you chose to ignore the post above and continue to state your opinion with a total disregard for it, then my judgment will be wrong. Also, whenever I do anything around here, very often I get criticism, yes, but very, very seldom do I get any kind of idea of what I should be doing more of. It often just seems like whatever I do is just not good enough, since people tend to refuse to tell me what was good. I know there's always room for improvement, and I know I sound childish kind of wishing for some praise, but I do my very best to point out what went right nearly every time I comment on someone's work, along with whatever criticism, and forgive me if I hope for some of the same treatment on something of my own. I'm tempted to start pulling examples from each and every topic (except for Item Sprites, I guess) but I really don't think I need to.
Read over your post again. How can someone not take offense to that? How can someone not be in a bad mood when you choose very distinctly to underline "soooooooooo awkward." The whole tone of the post is very offensive, and just saying "no offense" is just the icing on the cake.
And I've looked over the sprite dozens of times and still don't see how the eye is off. I compared it to several canon sprites, which all use black and maybe a spot of dark colour with white along side it. I'm not blaming you here, but I just don't see it.
As for the other things, yes, I could make those changes, but I don't want to until a decision is made on dancer vs. mermaid. -ImunityBow
How I see this is NyteFyre is looking at it different than you. NyteFyre you are looking it as if her face is looking straight at you with her hair covering one eye. Ib you intended for her to be looking at her poke ball. I know this is not in my place to say this but I think NyteFyre overreacted, and Ib only sort of did that. I have to agree witth Ib that it is hard to get praise around here, and that noone will give him cunstructive critisism because they are a afraid of him. Aslong as you keep it from flaming I'm pretty sure he's not going to be mad. I mean he is a pretty darn reasonable guy.