I closed the poll because:
- It shouldn't even have been a poll at all.
- When asking for opinions on something like this, it shouldn't be public. This was just a flamewar waiting to happen.
Now as to the title screen, it is too large for one. For two, the Pokemon logo is horribly pixelated. Since the style is similar, I'm assuming you've already seen the temporary title screen I whipped up for Badara's playtest but here it is for others who may not have seen it:
If you want to make another attempt then it should be 480x320 so it will fit into RPG Maker's game screen. Here is the Pokemon Topaz logo so you can use it. You will need to resize it to fit your needs here, but it is a fair quality version that anybody can feel free to use to create stuff for Topaz.
I look forward to your next attempt.