"We nicknamed her Bean"
Status:
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 991
Having it linear isn't really a bad thing, especially since the region is so huge. There should be enough side quests and main storyline that just because the gyms are in a pretty linear configuation, it won't mean that the adventure will be. Also, it wouldn't make a lot of sense to have too many "this gym is closed" things that you have to pass.
I think it's pretty accepted that the Caldera gyms are going to be the first three and the last three gyms (with Layla being flexible to slot in at the end as well), so it's really just a matter of moving the Kirant ones around. I think that XTS's order is fine, but if you want, here is a more complex, "less-linear" option if people aren't happy:
Fire
Flying
Grass
Fighting
[Poison gym is temporarily closed]
Rock
Light
Poison
Dragon
Ice
Ground
Dark
But it seems like an unnecessary amount of going back and forth