"We nicknamed her Bean"
Status:
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 991

Originally Posted by
Zenith
Second of all, the Dragon gym would really work better later, and having only a couple 'mons in the leader's lineup that late would make the fight too easy. And we can't make the Light gym too early because, again, Engil is the only one that isn't a final stage. Limiting the leader's lineup wouldn't fix that because even the Gym trainers will be using them.
The Dragon gym doesn't have to come later, and I'd actually prefer it to come sooner rather than later to break the mold that seems to be formed of Dragon trainers automatically being elite (Lance and Drake in the E4, Clair as the final gym leader). And even if the Light gym is "early-ish," it will still be fine. At the earliest, it will be gym 5, which has had pretty powerful Pokemon to it in the past. Besides, Purior and Seraph are both single stages and there are plenty of Pokemon we could include as Light kind-of types, so those are viable if we need to use them.

Originally Posted by
Zenith
Okay, I can see what you mean about Crawdaunt. A few of the gym trainers can use it. Vilephist, Serberine, and Abyssus are all physical sweepers, and I wanted to limit the amount of similar-styled 'mons on the same team. Abyssus also works better with the "overcoming fear" philosophy of the gym that we seem to be agreeing on. I want to leave Malduval in to stop Bug sweeps...maybe Dionare would work, to stop Fighting sweeps. And since Layla's gym would be the last of 12, her team would probably be high enough for her to actually use Raiger.
Dionare can't be used, it's a starter.
You'll also note that none of the canon gyms are putting as much competitive thought into their gyms as you are. You could easily sweep most of the Jhoto and Hoenn gyms with a single type quite easily. And many of them used the same types of Pokemon. It's nice that we have someone to think about these things, but I would prefer putting more aesthetic thought into the line-ups, then think more competitive when it come to move sets. But that's just me.
Is that really our only choice? Ouch. Rhydon's typing is really bad, and its stats aren't good enough to make up for it (unlike Rhyperior). Rhydon would work better in the Rock gym, trainers in Osiro's gym could still use it. Cragoyle seems more like something Therma would have on her rematch team.
Cragoyle would actually be well suited to a Rock gym. Re-match teams are a thing of the distant future.
And some miscellaneous ideas:
-The Normal leader's signature 'mon could be Zantilidae. I would actually recommend having the Normal gym fourth in this case.
-Reducing Froy's lineup to 2 and Fernando's lineup to 3 is more for balance, especially in Froy's case. Players won't have that many options for stuff to catch early on.
-Fernando can't have both Wolvine and Phantern. I would recommend changing the Wolvine to Canileaf.
-And are we gonna change Topaz Phantern's name, so people don't confuse it with OI Phantern?
-The last 5 gyms could be Tristan (wherever)->Christina (Skobeloff Village)->Dragon leader (wherever)->Osiro (Saharan City)->Layla (Aquapolis). I actually have a plan for the Dragon one, but that ties into map stuff.
-We need to figure out badge names for the new Gyms, and what TMs they give out. We might need to add more TMs.
-Yes
-Sure
-If I had to choose, I would rather have him keep Wolvine and save Phantern for the Ghost E4. Wolvine has nowhere else to be since we're scrapping the Fighting gym
-We discussed this, and I think we decided that on OI, the name would be changed to... something that I can't remember, but as far as Topaz is concerned, it will stay the same
-That's a lot of back and forth in a really spread out region. Kanto was fine because it was dense and there were lots of routes to take, but I would prefer to have Gerad, Christina and Osiro together if possible, then we can mess around with the order of the Kirant gyms (as the bulk of the plot line will occur here anyway, which can facilitate the gym order and vice-versa)
-I'm not sure what the TM list looks like, but I hadn't thought about that. If it is an issue, we could stick with 8 original TM's (obviously moving Mandy and Hanzo's to appropriate subs) and have the others give out some other item. Or just have the Kirant gyms give out another kind of item and the Caldera give out TM's. That might help to separate the "two leagues." The badge names will probably be easy, but that should wait until we have a firmer grip on what these gyms are going to be. Once all of that is finalized, we can worry about the little things.