Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
The Dragon gym doesn't have to come later, and I'd actually prefer it to come sooner rather than later to break the mold that seems to be formed of Dragon trainers automatically being elite (Lance and Drake in the E4, Clair as the final gym leader).
Most dragons are just too damn strong for early gyms. They resist all three starter types, their attacks have incredible neutral coverage, and every one of them in canon besides Altaria is OU or better right now. I recommended putting the Dragon gym 10th, roughly equivalent to the 7th gym in an 8-gym system, which is still earlier than it's ever been.

Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
And even if the Light gym is "early-ish," it will still be fine. At the earliest, it will be gym 5, which has had pretty powerful Pokemon to it in the past. Besides, Purior and Seraph are both single stages and there are plenty of Pokemon we could include as Light kind-of types, so those are viable if we need to use them.
The 5th gym in an 8-gym system is just past halfway. The 5th gym in a 12-gym system isn't even halfway. We also want to avoid using pseudo-types if at all possible. They're only used when there aren't enough of a certain type for the gym to work at any point, or when an earlier form isn't the right type, but its evolution is.

Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
Dionare can't be used, it's a starter.
Gardenia uses Turtwig. Flint uses Infernape. Jasmine has Empoleon in her rematch team. I rest my case. >_>

Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
You'll also note that none of the canon gyms are putting as much competitive thought into their gyms as you are. You could easily sweep most of the Jhoto and Hoenn gyms with a single type quite easily. And many of them used the same types of Pokemon. It's nice that we have someone to think about these things, but I would prefer putting more aesthetic thought into the line-ups, then think more competitive when it come to move sets. But that's just me.
Well, think about it. The Leaders use teams specifically to test amateur trainers. They're gonna make it harder over time. When a Dark gym is the last one you face, the leader isn't gonna just run a team that, say, Primeape can effortlessly sweep. Gamefreak just happens to not have a very good idea competitively. Furthermore, our target audience is gonna be older, as younger kids usually won't download a game like this by themselves, so we can afford to step the difficulty up a little.

Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
Cragoyle would actually be well suited to a Rock gym. Re-match teams are a thing of the distant future.
I looked up the Rhyhorn line. Turns out Rhyhorn doesn't turn into Rhydon until Level 42. So it really would work better with Osiro.

Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
If I had to choose, I would rather have him keep Wolvine and save Phantern for the Ghost E4. Wolvine has nowhere else to be since we're scrapping the Fighting gym.
The only problem I have with that is that Wolvine has no reason to use Cherry Bomb. And it wouldn't be like a League member to give Cherry Bomb to something that learns Leaf Blade naturally. On the other hand, the Jackalant line's Physical Attack is crap.

Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
That's a lot of back and forth in a really spread out region. Kanto was fine because it was dense and there were lots of routes to take, but I would prefer to have Gerad, Christina and Osiro together if possible, then we can mess around with the order of the Kirant gyms (as the bulk of the plot line will occur here anyway, which can facilitate the gym order and vice-versa)
I have a plan to make it work better. I'll get it typed up...tomorrow. And since the 7th or 8th badge will probably be the one to unlock Fly, some backtracking won't be a concern.

Quote Originally Posted by Reliability View Post
I'm not sure what the TM list looks like, but I hadn't thought about that. If it is an issue, we could stick with 8 original TM's (obviously moving Mandy and Hanzo's to appropriate subs) and have the others give out some other item. Or just have the Kirant gyms give out another kind of item and the Caldera give out TM's. That might help to separate the "two leagues."
It's still one League, it just covers two distinct areas. And having just eight leaders give out TMs would feel kind of...strange. Why would the C/K League not regulate that?