RPG Administrator
Status:
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: .......................
Posts: 1,082
While you both put out nice arguments, i think there can be a compromise.
On the competitiveness, I don't think Zenith was talking about making them like people do on Battle.net, but something similar, like having movesets that work well, and have coverage, at least in the later gyms. I agree that there should be a bit more competitiveness when facing the leaders, but make sure not to over-do it.
I always hated backtracking, and actually, in every generation, there has been backtracking in some way shape or form. Norman has to be passed up early in Gen 3, there's Hearthome in Gen 4, Kanto has a ton, and there's Olivine in Jhoto. Face it, there is always going to be forced backtracking in Canon games. I say we leave backtracking for after the E4, for like items/areas you couldn't reach previously, and such.
From my experience, XTS's idea for Wolvine is fine. Not every pokemon a gym leader has will have his signature move. In fact, it's usually reserved for their last, most powerful pokemon.
Distinct Regions giving out different items is fine for me. I hate some of the TMs you get from leaders, some i never use, or only the early ones, cause i need more powerful moves. That's it. I'd rather get hold items i can use, over TMs i won't. I think the first 3, which i believe are in Caldera, should give out TMs, to help you along, then the ones in Kirant give out Hold Items to help boost your game, then the last 3 give out TMs you will actually use, and are good to have. but that's just me.
I don't particularly like starters, and usually box mine after a certain amount of time, except for Jhoto, love my Typhlosion to death. I wouldn't care if trainers use them, or even gym trainers, but i would rather not see the Gym Leaders using them, or the E4 for that matter.
I'd like the idea of a battle that, even if you train well, and have a good team, you can still get your ass kicked by only 2 pokemon. I'm for the Chuck-Esque Dragon Gym. I never liked the predictable steady increase in the number of pokemon a leader uses, and think it would be a unique experience. Like how Inev is only using an Espeon on OI, but due to that, it is really tough.
NINJA! <-- Click here for Profile.