Actually I myself was leaning towards the more detailed icons. They look a lot nicer and gives you a lot more freedom, and still shouldn't take too long. There should only be around 70 or so (lol only) returning Pokemon so if I could handle those all alone I can leave Tyrannigon64 to do his stuff. The main quirk I have about fangames is that rather than take advantage of the fact it's played on a PC, meaning a lot more options graphics wise among other things that they still stick towards the limited style of the gba/ds, with their 16 colour palettes and small overworlds/tiles and things. I'm not sure how difficult it could be to fully make it into a 3D game, but we do have the space to create more detailed sprites and other things, while still keeping the main system of Pokemon games (overworld map, battle system, etc.)

But I guess we may be aiming for nostalgia here, so I don't know. I'll get to work on a tutorial or something if there are more opinions that lean towards keeping everything looking as if this was a real game released by Nintendo for a console.