It isn't that A is lying, it's that he isn't telling the truth. He has to tell you what you're supposed to do. Him saying "That person is the gym leader you must face" is too confusing to figure out whether it's a lie or not. It is partially true, because one of the liars (him) is the gym leader, and partially false because he says that the only liar is the gym leader. I used a command because that's the only way I could think of to get the information across to the player without him technically telling the truth. We need to find some way for him to tell you what to do without telling the truth.
What easy logic did you use to rule out BCDE and F? It may not work due to the possibility of H telling the truth, therefore there could possibly be two liars. I'm guessing you used the logic of "If X says Y is telling the truth, X must be telling the truth, because if he was lying, they would both be lying", but both of them lying could technically happen because there is the possibility of two liars.


Reply With Quote