I thought of an alternative: there can be a back room, and the door to it is locked. A says "When you find the liar, you will be able to go to the back room, where Layla is waiting." This is not true, as A is Layla, but isn't confusing as it is in no way true. Also, how should one accuse a person of being a liar, without it being obvious that you are able to accuse A? I would suggest the use of a key on the keyboard that isn't normally used. I also came up with another idea. At the end of every person's statement, they say "Keep in mind that if you accuse me as a liar, you will have to battle me." which is only true if a truth-teller says it, and is only a lie if a liar says it. Probably not a very good idea, but no harm in mentioning it, right?


Reply With Quote