I own PH and i remember that part it was 6 people which was interesting.. As to the liar test, yes it's been done plenty of times before, i remember having to do tons of it in school for a while, nearly drove me insane cause i couldnt get it right for years.... (i finally did when i played PH though)
From what i've played of the Pokemon series no i dont think that they've ever done this anywhere in there so it would be great to have this in the game especially when dealing with the gym leader.
Unfortunately there's a slight problem with this particular puzzle. People who don't want to go through the trouble of finding the leader will by-pass identifying the 2 liars and just battle everyone in there until they've found the gym leader.
I actually remember when i went through the 5th gym in Diamond that i solved the problems but i forgot to go back and battle the trainers so i was in some major trouble as my pokes weren't leveled up from it, it bit me in the butt when i fought the E4 but i managed to get through alive.
I just think that something else should be set up in the gym so that you would have to (more or less) fight everyone even if you did figure out the solution.
I believe Wake's gym from PDP, and a few from RSE could also be solved without ever going through trainers.
(I'm not saying remove all alternative paths but make it so that one isn't clearly identifiable.)
Thought just occurred to me: in RSE there's a gym where it's dark inside and you would have to go through it blind till you found the leader, But if you've been through it several times you could just go visit him if without ever fighting the trainers. So how exactly would we try to make it harder for people to find the easy-to-follow alt. path once discovered?

Reply With Quote