While I do believe that a TRPG provides some much needed traffic and a reason for people to keep coming back, we need to look at the benefits gained and how they synchronize with what we want to do:
- How many of these people can we "divert" into doing Topaz stuff?
- This is important since from my perspective the main point of a TRPG is to generate traffic. If people are on the forums, then in the best case scenario they'll look away from their own topics sometimes and contribute some stuff to Topaz.
- Currently a few people have started making an OI game, and they've managed to procure one spriter to help do everything. There are three people working on the project and there's no real interest other than that.
- The Turquoise TRPG ended up being mostly a flop since all focus just shifted there instead of a real game being made. I think Chronicler ended up giving up on the idea of a game in the end.
- What about our other general topics? People who post regularly on other things (the most extreme example I can think of in Topaz history is sifira who has stuck on one topic pretty much the whole time) haven't really often transferred into trying to help out elsewhere.
Also, ragingprimeape and Mediocrity_Incarnate may not contribute in terms of spriting, art, coding, mapping or sound, but there are other important aspects to the game. You know how Encounter Rates were open to all, were easy for anyone to do, were even fun to do (since choosing which Pokemon go where is pretty interesting), but only XTS and I ever did anything on it until RP/MI came out and helped out. Similar case with TehLurker 8 months ago, he had no unique skills to deploy in Topaz aspects but still ended up being one of the few to contribute in terms of Trainer Lineups and other things that anyone COULD do, but no one was WILLING to do. RP and MI have really been helping fill things out, and at least RP has proved himself a decent writer by passing the mod applications on OI - which means that the TRPG could be taking away from us script-writing wise.
Of course, I'm just putting down everything I can think of against the TRPG right now just to have counterarguments, in the end I'm not really convinced either way.