There's a bit of a chain here, and it's pretty funny.
Neon quoted BT.
Piro quoted Neon.
I quoted Neon and Piro.
And now everyone's quoting me as having said that we're trying not to use simple recolours.
Anyway, it's not just me, it's been a long-standing general consensus. The main reason I've been generally averse to non-scratch sprites is because I see the sprites and think they're so amazing, but then later am disappointed to find out they're just recolours :X I don't think I've outright said that recolours and edits will plain not be accepted, but probably have given that impression given my behaviour towards them.
Anyway, Diamond Dust will do as a placeholder if it really is the sprite for all dust-related items. Of course, a scratch is immediately preferable, but if that's the tradition I won't argue against it. I think though that the blue is too dark.
Magic Herb looks decidedly plain, I don't think adding sparkles is the right thing to do here. That's more for an Edward Herb or something.
Solar Cell is another brave attempt at one of those difficult sprites no one seems to get. The main problem with it being that it looks like it's floating in midair rather than resting on something (like most items), because of the perspective you used. It also looks like a window. The main problem is that there's just no detail. It needs more tangibility: some kind of depth to it. A box for storing the power, for instance, or some soldered wires. Things like that.
Toxic Slime looks entirely fine.
The R on the Rocket Ball is really hard to make out, I think using another shade of red, one that is less saturated, will be helpful for making it more eye-pleasing. The Orion Ball's colour scheme could be changed, I think. Blue and orange rarely work out, trying something more like yellow/gold and blue-gray is more to what I imagine.
And Shrapnel looks great! It may look a little too regular and symmetrical, but you captured the effect brilliantly and it will definitely do.