Firstly, he didn't say that it's almost exactly what he should have made, he said it's almost exactly what he has made. Second, what is with your obsession with black bands? Most Pokeballs have a greyish-black bands (I'm pretty sure lighter than what you're talking about)

And there are some that have completely different coloured bands.



Finally, I don't think he was being rude. He was just stating that it looked almost exactly like what he made. Probably somewhat surprised that Nintendo came up with almost the same thing as he did.